Tribal groups challenge new limits on historic preservation lawsuits

by Adelaide Fairbanks • 7 hours ago
Tribal groups challenge new limits on historic preservation lawsuits
**Historic preservation site protest**.

The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law’s permitting reforms include a disputed provision that restricts judicial remedies for violations of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). This change has drawn criticism from tribes and some lawmakers, who argue it weakens their ability to challenge federal actions affecting sacred sites or cultural heritage. Some Democratic senators have proposed giving tribes an exemption from the provision that prohibits courts from vacating agency decisions for NHPA violations.

The debate over remedy restrictions also intersects with tribal sovereignty arguments, which strengthen the case for limiting National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) litigation within reservation boundaries. However, extending such exemptions beyond tribal lands introduces new complications. These inconsistencies show why the remedy restrictions remain one of the most contentious elements of the bill, even as they form a central compromise in the bipartisan agreement.

The bill currently provides that courts treat challenges to the agency responses to remands for NEPA violations like original challenges to agency NEPA compliance, with similar limitations on remedy. Legal scholars counter that remand responses should be handled differently. After all, the agency already has violated NEPA in way that has been specifically identified by the court, been given 180 days to fix the problem, and been able to initiate work on the project (absent a preliminary injunction because of another legal violation and irreparable harm). Such noncompliance may justify stronger judicial intervention, including the power to vacate the agency’s decision until the violation is resolved.

Such a judicial power might be particularly important if the original NEPA violation by the agency was a complete failure to conduct NEPA analysis. Under the current framework, an agency could repeatedly pledge to complete the review, delay indefinitely, and force courts into a cycle of remands while the project advances. Perhaps contempt and sanctions are available to the court to address such a situation. I am skeptical that such an approach will be sufficient for this Administration – see the DC golf course case… Allowing vacatur for repeated remand failures could address these enforcement gaps.

Yet broader vacatur authority carries risks. If agencies or project sponsors anticipate judicial intervention after a remand, they may delay starting work during the 180-day compliance window. This uncertainty could undermine the bill’s goal of accelerating permitting by discouraging early project initiation.

A narrower approach would be to allow vacatur (or a preliminary injunction) for an agency failure to comply with a remand order only if the action would produce irreparable harm. This would concentrate judicial power on the most serious NEPA violations, reducing broader disruptions while still addressing genuine enforcement concerns. An even narrower solution would limit vacatur to instances of bad-faith agency noncompliance, directly targeting scenarios where agencies deliberately ignore court orders.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *