The Supreme Court on Friday issued a limited notice to the Union Government after a public interest litigation highlighted medical risks linked to consanguineous marriages.
Bench and petitioner
A three-judge bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana heard a petition filed by Charvi S., a 20-year-old law student with a 40% visual impairment.
Senior Advocate Kaadambari Singh appeared for the petitioner, who asked the Court to order measures that would address health hazards arising from marriages between close blood relatives.
Medical background and legal claim
Charvi S. was born with cone dystrophy, an inherited eye disorder that causes nystagmus, photophobia and severely reduced cone responses on electrophysiological testing.
Her condition limits colour discrimination, independent road crossing and routine daily activities, and it has disrupted her education because some schools could not meet her medical needs.
The petition argued that the State has a constitutional obligation to prevent foreseeable genetic harm to future generations, relying on her personal experience and medical literature.
Requested actions
The petition asks the Union of India to consider the desirability of suitable legislation, or to ensure wide publicity through different channels, including a proper curriculum in schools and colleges, to instil scientific temper towards the negative impacts of consanguineous marriages.
The bench noted that most reliefs fall within the legislative domain, yet agreed that public awareness is essential, even though marriage remains a personal choice.
Justice Bagchi recalled that courts have previously recognised the right to marry an HIV-infected person with knowledge, and stressed that individuals should be able to make an “informed decision” about close-kin unions.
Singh told the Court that the practice is mostly prevalent in rural areas where awareness is limited. “At least people should be apprised of the adverse consequences through wide publicity and some structured information system,” she said.
Statutory challenges
The petition was filed under Article 32 of the Constitution by a student of the National Law School of India University, Bengaluru, who herself is the offspring of a first-cousin marriage within the Reddy community.
It questions the statutory exceptions that permit marriages within prohibited degrees of relationship under Sections 5(iv) and 5(v) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and Section 4(d) of the Special Marriage Act, 1954.
The petitioner argued that these customary exceptions are constitutionally problematic because they permit close-kin marriages despite medical evidence indicating an increased risk of genetic disorders and congenital conditions among their offspring.
Court’s limited notice
The Court’s notice is confined to urging the Union to examine the desirability of legislation or to launch a thorough awareness campaign; it does not seek to criminalise existing marriages or alter their legal status.
